• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE TO BYLINES SCOTLAND
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Bylines Scotland
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Bylines Scotland Breaking News
    • Europe
    • King Charles III
    • Queen Elizabeth II
    • Scotland
    • War in Ukraine
    • World
    Go Dharmic charity with Martin Dover

    Putting compassion into action – Coronation Champion Award winner Martin Dover leads the way.

    Police Investigation

    There’s been a murder

    Heart of NHS

    Back to the future

    Women health inequalities represented by a heart and a cardiogram

    Women’s Health in Scotland: challenges and progress

    Oil in Scotland

    Oil, Margaret Thatcher and Dinnae Mess Wi Us

    Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh

    Scotland’s Road to Devolution

    Poverty in Scotland

    Poverty in Scotland 2022

    NHS Scotland

    A Healthcare System that delivers for people?

    Scottish political calls

    Liberté, égalité, fraternité

    Trending Tags

    • Democracy
    • Devolution
    • Brexit
    • Ukraine
  • Politics
    • All
    • Council Areas
    • Europe
    • Holyrood
    • Liz Truss
    • Rest of UK
    • Tories
    • United Kingdom
    • Westminster
    • World
    UK voting system First-past-the-post

    Why is the UK still locked into an obsolete political system?

    Scottish Parliament Party seats

    People like to back the winning side.

    Post Election Blues

    Post-election blues

    Labour Anas Sarwar cartoon

    The challenge for Labour in Scotland

    Hard Labour

    Hard Labour

    Edinburgh Military Tattoo mixed with EU symbol

    Great visionaries brought us two great institutions that made life better for Scots and Scotland

    Westminster Government

    Regimes are at their most dangerous in their death throes 

    Rupert Murdoch portrait

    Why Rupert Murdoch should support Scotland’s independence.

    Demonstrator on the streets of London

    Eggs, black shirts and unsettled Britain

    Trending Tags

    • Equality
    • Johnson
    • Scottish National Party
  • Business
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Aviation
    • Corporations
    • Energy
    • Finance
    • Fishing
    • Natural Resources
    • Shipbuilding
    • Trade
    • Transport
    • Workers
    A crane in a port

    Forth and Clyde Drowned by the Thames and Mersey

    Scotland's green Freeport's

    Green freeports – gateway to sustainability or greenwashing with a tax avoidance cherry?

    Salmon covered by sea lice

    Anyone for sea lice risotto?

    Bakkafrost Barge

    The Story of the Bakkafrost Barge Sinking

    Fish farm in Scotland

    A deeper dive into the history of Scottish fish farming

    Fish farms in a Scottish Loch

    How farmed salmon is produced – stage one

    Dead salmons

    Death in our waters

    Fish farming, Isle of Sky, Loch Ainort

    Fish Farming in Scotland 

    Offshore wind farm

    How will local communities get a fair share of record investment from offshore wind farms?

    Trending Tags

    • Health
      • All
      • Assisted dying
      • Covid
      • Influenza
      • Polio virus
      • Respiratory
      • Scientific Research
      Illustration of an antibiotic running away from bacteria depicting antibiotic resistance

      Antibiotic resistance – a major global public health threat

      Slogan Still Home from Clinically Vulnerable Families group

      Covid-19 lockdown continues for many in the UK

      Tree representing lungs

      Where are the areas in Scotland most affected by lung conditions?

      Health service

      Funding the Scottish Health Service 

      A goose surrounded by avian flu

      Who is knocking our doors? A putative new pandemic?

      A woman walking in a field with a jerrycan of water on her back, spraying water on the vegetation

      The Ethiopia Medical Project

      Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

      “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

      Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

      Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

      A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

      Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

      Trending Tags

      • Environment
        • All
        • Air Pollution
        • Biology
        • Climate Change
        • Wildfires
        Balblair substation

        Desecrating the glens: the relentless march of the industrial triffids

        Salmon covered by sea lice

        Anyone for sea lice risotto?

        Diagram representing circular economy

        Local Authorities, communities and the circular economy

        Bakkafrost Barge

        The Story of the Bakkafrost Barge Sinking

        Fish farm in Scotland

        A deeper dive into the history of Scottish fish farming

        Fish farms in a Scottish Loch

        How farmed salmon is produced – stage one

        Dead salmons

        Death in our waters

        Fish farming, Isle of Sky, Loch Ainort

        Fish Farming in Scotland 

        Ardnish wildfire by Leslie Barrie, CC BY-SA 2.0 Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic — CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons'

        Fire threats in the Scottish countryside

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Bylines Scotland Breaking News
          • Europe
          • King Charles III
          • Queen Elizabeth II
          • Scotland
          • War in Ukraine
          • World
          Go Dharmic charity with Martin Dover

          Putting compassion into action – Coronation Champion Award winner Martin Dover leads the way.

          Police Investigation

          There’s been a murder

          Heart of NHS

          Back to the future

          Women health inequalities represented by a heart and a cardiogram

          Women’s Health in Scotland: challenges and progress

          Oil in Scotland

          Oil, Margaret Thatcher and Dinnae Mess Wi Us

          Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh

          Scotland’s Road to Devolution

          Poverty in Scotland

          Poverty in Scotland 2022

          NHS Scotland

          A Healthcare System that delivers for people?

          Scottish political calls

          Liberté, égalité, fraternité

          Trending Tags

          • Democracy
          • Devolution
          • Brexit
          • Ukraine
        • Politics
          • All
          • Council Areas
          • Europe
          • Holyrood
          • Liz Truss
          • Rest of UK
          • Tories
          • United Kingdom
          • Westminster
          • World
          UK voting system First-past-the-post

          Why is the UK still locked into an obsolete political system?

          Scottish Parliament Party seats

          People like to back the winning side.

          Post Election Blues

          Post-election blues

          Labour Anas Sarwar cartoon

          The challenge for Labour in Scotland

          Hard Labour

          Hard Labour

          Edinburgh Military Tattoo mixed with EU symbol

          Great visionaries brought us two great institutions that made life better for Scots and Scotland

          Westminster Government

          Regimes are at their most dangerous in their death throes 

          Rupert Murdoch portrait

          Why Rupert Murdoch should support Scotland’s independence.

          Demonstrator on the streets of London

          Eggs, black shirts and unsettled Britain

          Trending Tags

          • Equality
          • Johnson
          • Scottish National Party
        • Business
          • All
          • Agriculture
          • Aviation
          • Corporations
          • Energy
          • Finance
          • Fishing
          • Natural Resources
          • Shipbuilding
          • Trade
          • Transport
          • Workers
          A crane in a port

          Forth and Clyde Drowned by the Thames and Mersey

          Scotland's green Freeport's

          Green freeports – gateway to sustainability or greenwashing with a tax avoidance cherry?

          Salmon covered by sea lice

          Anyone for sea lice risotto?

          Bakkafrost Barge

          The Story of the Bakkafrost Barge Sinking

          Fish farm in Scotland

          A deeper dive into the history of Scottish fish farming

          Fish farms in a Scottish Loch

          How farmed salmon is produced – stage one

          Dead salmons

          Death in our waters

          Fish farming, Isle of Sky, Loch Ainort

          Fish Farming in Scotland 

          Offshore wind farm

          How will local communities get a fair share of record investment from offshore wind farms?

          Trending Tags

          • Health
            • All
            • Assisted dying
            • Covid
            • Influenza
            • Polio virus
            • Respiratory
            • Scientific Research
            Illustration of an antibiotic running away from bacteria depicting antibiotic resistance

            Antibiotic resistance – a major global public health threat

            Slogan Still Home from Clinically Vulnerable Families group

            Covid-19 lockdown continues for many in the UK

            Tree representing lungs

            Where are the areas in Scotland most affected by lung conditions?

            Health service

            Funding the Scottish Health Service 

            A goose surrounded by avian flu

            Who is knocking our doors? A putative new pandemic?

            A woman walking in a field with a jerrycan of water on her back, spraying water on the vegetation

            The Ethiopia Medical Project

            Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

            “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

            Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

            Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

            A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

            Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

            Trending Tags

            • Environment
              • All
              • Air Pollution
              • Biology
              • Climate Change
              • Wildfires
              Balblair substation

              Desecrating the glens: the relentless march of the industrial triffids

              Salmon covered by sea lice

              Anyone for sea lice risotto?

              Diagram representing circular economy

              Local Authorities, communities and the circular economy

              Bakkafrost Barge

              The Story of the Bakkafrost Barge Sinking

              Fish farm in Scotland

              A deeper dive into the history of Scottish fish farming

              Fish farms in a Scottish Loch

              How farmed salmon is produced – stage one

              Dead salmons

              Death in our waters

              Fish farming, Isle of Sky, Loch Ainort

              Fish Farming in Scotland 

              Ardnish wildfire by Leslie Barrie, CC BY-SA 2.0 Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic — CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons'

              Fire threats in the Scottish countryside

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
              No Result
              View All Result
              Bylines Scotland
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home Politics Holyrood

              Battle for Scotland’s soul begins when UK Supreme Court rules on IndyRef 2

              Nicola Sturgeon and Alister Jack will go head-to-head over whether the Scottish Parliament can hold an independence referendum – battle lines are being drawn

              Martin RochebyMartin Roche
              15-09-2022 09:16
              in Holyrood, Scotland, Scottish Independence, Westminster
              The Middlesex Guildhall, home of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom. Photograph by Tom Norris under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 license

              The Middlesex Guildhall, home of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom. Photograph by Tom Norris under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 license

              2.6k
              VIEWS
              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

              The government of Liz Truss has promised to see off any attempt to have a second independence referendum or to see the next general election become a de facto referendum. Led by Scottish Secretary Alister Jack, the forces of unionism are marshalling their constitutional arguments and PR machines.

              So, Alister Jack holds on to his Cabinet job as secretary of state for Scotland. At the start of the Tory leadership contest, I wrote that a change was probably on the cards. It was not to be. Jack is back. Truss has put her faith in the MP for Dumfries and Galloway to see off the prospect of a second independence referendum.

              Jack is a political babe in arms compared to Nicola Sturgeon, for whom politics and the politics of independence have been a lifelong endeavour. Jack’s political career began in 2017, when he won Dumfries and Galloway for the Tories. On winning the 2019 general election, Boris Johnson made him Scottish secretary.

              Battle lines are being drawn

              Jack’s time in charge has not seen a rise in the fortunes of his party in Scotland. Last year’s Holyrood elections saw the Tory party tread water, coming back to Edinburgh with the same number of seats as before. Only the SNP and the Scottish Greens increased their share of the vote.

              But the stage is being set for an occasion that will see Sturgeon and Jack go head to head over the result of the Supreme Court’s deliberation on whether the Scottish Parliament can hold an independence referendum without the consent of London. Few doubt that the Supreme Court will rule in London’s favour. It will most likely say that the powers over the constitution are reserved and that the wording of The Scotland Act (that enabled devolution) is unambiguous. But the court may comment on the idea that constitutional statute law should not be forever inflexible, particularly if it conflicts with the express wishes of voters.

              Whatever the outcome of the case, both sides will be busy now preparing their arguments. Jack will want to dismiss the idea of IndyRef2 as dead in the water. Sturgeon will argue it is simply a step along the way and that Scotland’s democratic wish has been frustrated by a London government with barely noticeable political legitimacy in Scotland.

              2024 general election in Scotland starts after Supreme Court ruling

              The end of the Supreme Court case will see the beginning of the 2024 general election campaign in Scotland. Sturgeon has said that this event will effectively be a referendum on independence. Numerous political, academic and media voices have dismissed the idea of a general election as a de facto referendum as ridiculous. General elections can be no place for big constitutional matters or single-issue campaigns, they argue. They have conveniently short memories.

              Theresa May and Boris Johnson fought the 2017 and 2019 general elections on the single issue of Brexit. In 1974, Conservative Prime Minister Heath asked, “who rules Britain, the trade unions or the government?” He called a snap general election with that question being the dominant theme. He lost, but parliamentary democracy won. All three general elections – 1974, 2017 and 2019 – were in essence single issue campaigns and of the most fundamental constitutional importance.

              During the long months of this year’s tedious Tory leadership contest, there was much talk of ‘Muscular Unionism’. Holyrood and the SNP government was to be held much more to account by Westminster and the London government would be robust about criticising SNP failures. We wait to see if Jack will open up this new front. There is little doubt that many in the Tory party would happily close Holyrood and return Scotland to the Viceroy-like rule that ran from The Duke of Argyll in 1707 to Michael Forsyth in 1997.

              Go Dharmic charity with Martin Dover
              Scotland

              Putting compassion into action – Coronation Champion Award winner Martin Dover leads the way.

              byThomas Greengrass
              28 May 2023

              Holyrood will remain

              Closing Holyrood is not on the cards. The idea is to weaken it and in so doing undermine the status and authority of the first minister and the parties of independence (this may be a good moment to remind unionists that in 1997 Scotland voted 73.4% for the creation of the Scottish parliament).

              The secretary of state’s door may be more open than in the past to local councils that want to tap into central government funds. He who pays the piper will expect to have at least some say in the tune that is later played to the public about the source of funds. The secretary of state’s spin doctors are likely to be told to up their game. No attack opportunity is to be ignored. Jack’s two junior ministers will be told to double their efforts to promote the union, as will Scottish Tory MPs. Labour and SNP owe each other no favours. Labour will sup with the Tories if convenient.

              Hereof and forever after

              Among the arguments for union will be the reinforcement of the status of the 1707 Act of Union as an unbreakable treaty. They will quote the Act, which begins as follows:

              “That the Two Kingdoms of Scotland and England shall upon the first day of May next ensuing the date hereof and forever after be United into One Kingdom by the Name of Great Britain.”

              Had the British state not already selectively interfered with the Act of Union the Tories might have a case. But it has. Here are three examples.

              In granting the 2014 Scottish independence referendum, Westminster recognised that the Act of Union was not unbreakable, as a Yes vote in 2014 would have seen the Act fall when Scotland left the union. It cannot now be credible, or perhaps even sensible, for the unionist camp to say that Act of Union is “forever after”.

              “Contrary to or inconsistent”

              The Act was also shown to be subject to change when the Local Government Act (Scotland) Act was used to abolish Scotland’s Royal Boroughs. Clause 21 of the 1707 Act says, “That the Rights and Privileges of the Royall Burroughs in Scotland as they now are Do Remain entire after the Union”. Because it was convenient to the administration of the day, what was once seen as a vital and central clause of the Act of Union was pushed aside. It was part of the 1973 Conservative government’s manifesto commitment to reform local government in Scotland. Democracy had spoken and been respected.

              In 1707 Scotland’s Peers were included in the Act of Union and given the same legal status as English Peers. “Shall Enjoy all Privileges of Peers as fully as the Peers of England do now or as they or any other Peers of Great Britain may hereafter Enjoy the same.”

              They didn’t even then have parity, as only 16 Scottish Peers were to be given seats in the House of Lords. But the legal right of 16 Peers from Scotland to sit in the Lords was of no consequence when the government of Tony Blair ended the automatic right of hereditary Peers to sit in the Lords. The 1707 Act of Union had no effect. But the 1707 Act is the law of the UK, as ratified by the parliaments of Scotland and England over 300 years ago. It seems its provisions are to be ignored when convenient to Westminster but to be sworn as Holy Writ when it suits the unionist cause.

              The Act of Union says any “laws and statutes contrary to or inconsistent with the terms” of the Act would “cease and become void”. Ending the Royall Burroughs was clearly inconsistent, yet it happened. Removing Scottish hereditary Peers was inconsistent, but it happened, and the sky did not fall in.

              The 1707 Act also created a customs union and a monetary union. We were in an EU customs union, but parliament legislated us out of that. Parliament is sovereign. It can do anything it wishes. It made the 1707 Act of Union, and it can unmake it.

              Democracy can’t be ignored

              There is also the small matter of the long-standing constitutional convention that no parliament can bind a future parliament. We saw that at work with Brexit and our extraction from the EU. Just as parliament voted for the UK’s adoption of the Treaty of Rome and its successor treaties, so a later parliament enacted laws to end what had been a fully legally bound set of treaties. There is nothing to stop a so-minded Westminster parliament repealing the 1707 Act of Union.

              If Labour needed SNP support to form a government and the SNP had secured an overwhelming mandate from the Scottish electorate, the price of few years of cooperation might just be the eventual end of the 1707 Act. In any case, if the independence side won a referendum the Act would have to be repealed. Westminster simply could not ignore such a democratic mandate.

              The idea that the 1707 Act is of a higher caste than any other piece of legislation does not stand up to historic scrutiny, legal precedent, natural justice, or the supreme logic of the democratic mandate. In short, the wishes of the voters are the highest court in any democracy.


              We need your help! The press in our country is dominated by billionaire-owned media, many offshore and avoiding paying tax. We are a citizen journalism publication but still have significant costs. If you believe in what we do, please consider subscribing to the Bylines Gazette 🙏

              Tags: HolyroodIndyRef2Nicola SturgeonSupreme Court
              Previous Post

              Massive air defence exercise taking place over Scotland

              Next Post

              How do we care for Scotland’s mountain footpath network?

              Martin Roche

              Martin Roche

              Aged 15, Martin began his working life on a Scottish evening newspaper. He then ran his family business before reading politics and international relations at Aberdeen University, as a mature student. He worked in London in investment promotion attraction for Scottish development agencies, followed by a 35-year career in international PR consultancy. He has been a columnist on African Leadership magazine, commenting on geopolitics, a regular contributor to foreign direct investment media and has written for business publications worldwide. He recently returned to Scotland. He lives in Glasgow.

              Related Posts

              Go Dharmic charity with Martin Dover
              Scotland

              Putting compassion into action – Coronation Champion Award winner Martin Dover leads the way.

              byThomas Greengrass
              28 May 2023
              Police Investigation
              Opinion

              There’s been a murder

              byMartin Roche
              26 May 2023
              Heart of NHS
              NHS Scotland

              Back to the future

              byLynne Copland
              20 May 2023
              Women health inequalities represented by a heart and a cardiogram
              NHS Scotland

              Women’s Health in Scotland: challenges and progress

              byDr Patricia S Paton
              16 May 2023
              Oil in Scotland
              History

              Oil, Margaret Thatcher and Dinnae Mess Wi Us

              byMartin Roche
              14 May 2023
              Next Post
              Scotland's mountain footpaths

              How do we care for Scotland’s mountain footpath network?

              PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

              Subscribe to our newsletters
              CHOOSE YOUR NEWS
              Follow us on social media
              CHOOSE YOUR PLATFORMS
              Download our app
              ALL OF BYLINES IN ONE PLACE
              Subscribe to our gazette
              CONTRIBUTE TO OUR SUSTAINABILITY
              Make a monthly or one-off donation
              DONATE NOW
              Help us with our hosting costs
              SIGN UP TO SITEGROUND
              We are always looking for citizen journalists
              WRITE FOR US
              Volunteer as an editor, in a technical role, or on social media
              VOLUNTEER FOR US
              Something else?
              GET IN TOUCH
              Previous slide
              Next slide

              LATEST

              Go Dharmic charity with Martin Dover

              Putting compassion into action – Coronation Champion Award winner Martin Dover leads the way.

              28 May 2023
              UK voting system First-past-the-post

              Why is the UK still locked into an obsolete political system?

              27 May 2023
              Police Investigation

              There’s been a murder

              26 May 2023
              Brexit impact illustration

              Brexit Stock Take

              24 May 2023

              MOST READ

              UK voting system First-past-the-post

              Why is the UK still locked into an obsolete political system?

              27 May 2023
              Brexit impact illustration

              Brexit Stock Take

              24 May 2023
              King Charles Coronation and the United Kingdom Flag

              Coronation Chickens … coming home to roost

              29 April 2023
              Police Investigation

              There’s been a murder

              26 May 2023

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Brexit Christmas ClimateChange Covid Covid19 Culture Defence Democracy Devolution election FishFarms Glasgow Halloween health History Holyrood independence IndyRef2 Johnson Journalism Labour LGBT+ Liz Truss Monarchy NATO NHS Nicola Sturgeon politics Poverty Pro-EU Public Health Putin Russia Sars-CoV-2 Scotland Security and Defence shipbuilding SNP Sunak Tories Tourism Twitter Ukraine UK Supreme Court War in Ukraine
              Bylines Scotland

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Scotland and beyond.

              Bylines Scotland is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a partner organisation to Byline Times.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Network
              • About
              • Authors
              • Contact
              • Donate
              • Privacy

              © 2023 Bylines Scotland. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Scotland
                • World
              • Politics
                • Council Areas
                • Europe
                • Holyrood
                • Rest of UK
                • Westminster
              • Business
                • Fishing
                • Trade
                • Transport
              • Health
              • Environment
                • Climate Change
              • Opinion
              • Donate
              • Newsletter sign up
              CROWDFUNDER

              © 2023 Bylines Scotland. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In