• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Bylines Scotland
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Health
  • Environment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Health
  • Environment
  • Opinion
No Result
View All Result
Bylines Scotland
No Result
View All Result
Home Lifestyle History

But where are you from really?

The real-life experiences of the internment of “Enemy Alien” civilians in Britain during the Second World War.

Tanya Pia StarrettbyTanya Pia Starrett
04-09-2022 08:00
in History
Reading Time: 11 mins read
A A
Old photo of mums

Photo by author. Printed with permission

317
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

My “Nonno” (grandfather) Tomasso Pia was born into poverty in the Abruzzo region of Italy in 1895. Having fought in the First World War alongside his British and French allies he, like thousands of other Italian men in the immediate post war years, left his homeland and emigrated to Scotland. (photo 1 of Nonno in uniform) A success both in business and at home, his new life brought a degree of wealth that could not have been achieved in the Italy of the 1920s and 30s.

Photo of Tommaso Pia
Photo by author. Printed with permission

He built up a successful café business in the Maryhill area of Glasgow and had three daughters, the youngest of whom was my mother. He had already lived in Scotland for 20 years when, on the morning of 1 June 1940, two days after Italy declared war on Great Britain and France, he was arrested as an “enemy alien” and spent the next three years in an internment camp on the Isle of Man. (photo 2 of the café).

Photo of the cafe
Photo by author. Printed with permission

“Collar the Lot”

As early as October 1939, only a month after Britain declared war on Germany, internment tribunals had begun. Many cases heard were of Germans and Austrians living in Britain, many of whom were Jewish refugees. There were three tribunal categories assigned to individuals. Those in Category A were deemed an immediate risk and were to be interned at once. Category B was assigned to those who, subject to certain restrictions, were allowed to remain at liberty. The final Category C meant, in the eyes of the tribunals, that no risk was posed to the general population.

Early on, cracks in the internment policy were already evident, especially in identifying and classifying Italian fascists and anti-fascists. Attempts to adopt an equitable classification tribunal system quickly broke down in the weeks following Italy’s entry into the war in June 1940. On 10 June it was decided that a policy of general internment had to be adopted. This implemented Churchill’s instruction to “collar the lot”, which he had issued to the Ministry of Home Security on 11 June 1940 just a day after Italy’s entry to the War. At this point around 4,000, mostly Italian men, were arrested.

Shaping Public Opinion

Thanks to the pioneering contemporary social research project Mass Observation Survey, which began in 1937, it is possible to gauge how public opinion on the internment policy changed during the spring and summer of 1940. The survey was carried out to measure general attitudes towards aforementioned “enemy aliens” under the then umbrella term of the “Fifth Column”. Reporting in April 1940, the survey found that most Britons didn’t know the meaning of “Fifth Column”.

Detailed interviews in London as well as the west coast of Scotland revealed that less than one person in a hundred stated that enemy aliens ought to be interned en masse. By May 1940, however, public opinion had noticeably changed, leading the survey’s author, Tom Harrison, to write in the New Statesman in July 1940 that,

“many people who a month before were inclined to be tolerant of aliens were now almost pogrom minded.”

In the weeks and months leading up to Italy’s entry into the war there had been a growing campaign of press hostility towards Italians living in Britain. It was against this background that the Labour MP Rhys Davis, in a House of Commons debate on 22 August 1940, lamented how an admittedly flawed selection process had given way to wholesale internment stating,

“the press howled intern the lot and the Government succumbed … that is a lesson to us all not to follow the dictates of the newspapers.”

Families depicted.
History

The Tinker experiment

byCharlie McCarthy
19 August 2022

A Camp, Not a Holiday

SurnameForenameNo.Nat.MiscellaneousSource
PiaTommaso62532ItalianHouse 28,
“O” Camp,
Onchan Camp.
– Date of Birth 5.8.1885
in Picinisco.
– Still in Onchan29.5.1943.
– Released from
Onchan Camp 27.8.1943.
From MNHL
MS 11551/4
(TNA HO 215/475)
Onchan Camp
Nominal Roll 1943.

According to Nonno’s camp record, there is no mention of what category he was deemed. Nobody knows to this day. He did not attend a tribunal and was taken directly to the Isle of Man camp. He was not a fascist or a member of any fascist party. The Isle of Man museum, which manages the archives from that period, reported that there was a fire there immediately after the end of the Second World War, which destroyed many of the documents.

The island camps, which had been similarly used in the First World War, included terraced streets of pre-war bed and breakfast boarding houses surrounded by barbed wire fences. The camps had space for over 10,000 internees with “Onchan” camp housing my Nonno as a café owner alongside restaurant owners. Researchers have noted that, in addition to Italians, there were Austrian and German Jewish refugees as well as a number of Irish, Scottish and Welsh nationalists. (photo 3 pictured at Isle of Man Camp, 1940-1943 – my grandfather-back row, first left with hat and moustache and photo 4 Onchan camp. Photo of barbed wire promenade)

Internees at Ice of Man Camp
Photo by author. Printed with permission
Photo of Onchan Camp 1940
Photo by author. Printed with permission

The day-to-day routine within these camps varied little. The alarm would sound at 7am and after physical exercise, breakfast would be taken communally in the camps. There would be regular parades and escorted walks out of the barbed wire confines along the Douglas front. There was no furniture, towels and very little soap and toilet paper in these camps. Nearly half the men interned were over fifty with many in poor health. Feelings of uselessness and boredom were constant, which often led to depression and, in some cases, suicide.

 Back on Civvy Street

Tommaso Pia was released on 27 August 1943, a month after Mussolini was deposed and arrested by his own Grand Council. On 13 October that year, Italy joined the Allied side and declared war on its former Axis partner, Germany. By the time he returned to the café, there were American troops based in the nearby Maryhill barracks. My mother used to remember them coming into the café with powdered chocolate so that my Grandfather could make them chocolate ice-cream. This he did, but in the same breath, he would also refuse to serve any GI Joe who would not sit beside a fellow American who happened to be black.

The café continued to do well for the family. (photo 5 of family studio photo). The fact that cigarettes were not rationed had sustained it through the austere war years, while the 1950s saw chocolate coming “off the ration”, which was good news for café owners. Up until his death in 1960, my grandfather, like many of his generation, would never speak about his time in the Isle of Man camp except to say that in times of extreme hunger they were often forced to eat grass. By the time of his death in 1960 at the age of 65 my Grandfather had spent 40 years living and working in Scotland and 3 years as an interned “enemy alien” on the Isle of Man.

Family studio photo
Photo by author. Printed with permission

 What it is to be British

The debates and issues being raised in Parliament and the wider media were, in many respects, very modern and just as relevant today: Rwanda, anyone? While current politicians try to determine what it is to be “British”, the realities of wartime Britain bring an added lucidity to this debate. Bravely writing at the time in 1940, Francois Lafitte, a researcher with the Institute for Social and Economic Research and fierce opponent of the internment policy, wrote that

“the real aliens are the Nazis of the soul of all countries … our real friends are not to be judged by tests of birthplace or language but by their present conduct.” 

Similarly, Labour MP William Wedgwood Benn suggested in a Commons debate on 22 August 1940 that the “only aliens are the people who believe in the Nazi form of religion” and that this could not be determined by country of birth. Similarly, Harold Nicholson, Labour parliamentary secretary for the Ministry of Information, stated that“ in the last war the agents used by Germany were either neutral citizens or British traitors.” 

By urging an examination of belief structures among individuals and groups these contemporary MPs and writers were hoping to shine a light on the role of organisations such as “The Right Club”. Founded by Archibald Maule Ramsey, the Scottish Unionist MP for Peebles and Southern Midlothian, the Right Club sought to unify all the different right-wing groups in Britain at that time. Their main objective was to “oppose and expose the activities of organized Jewry.” Their membership attracted many among the British upper classes who had racist right-wing ideals and very strong Nazi sympathies. Although Ramsey himself was later imprisoned, many within this group were never interned.

Policy on the ‘other’ always there and evolving

Similar internment policies existed elsewhere. In the US, for example, of the 695,000 Italians living in the US, some 1,881 were detained as enemy aliens. As a proportion, however, Britain detained far more. Many Italians in Britain felt ashamed and wanted to quickly forget about this sorry chapter and move on with their lives and families, which they did. Without an apology and without compensation.

From Internment to Windrush, from the EU settlement scheme to asylum seekers and refugees sent to Rwanda (thankfully no one has been sent to date), UK government policy on the ‘other’ never goes away and only ever evolves. What contemporary writers and commentators were emphasising at the time, is that it’s one thing to criticise policies but at the end of the day it’s individuals, families and livelihoods all with their own faces and personalities that are ultimately affected.

When I look at an old post-war photograph of my grandfather, I realise that it is not a resigned expression on his face but one of dignified silence.

Post-war photograph of grandfather
Photo by author. Printed with permission

We need your help!

The press in our country is dominated by billionaire-owned media, many offshore and avoiding paying tax. We are a citizen journalism publication but still have significant costs.

If you believe in what we do, please consider subscribing to the Bylines Gazette from as little as £2 a month🙏

Tags: internmentIsle of ManWW2
Previous Post

Putting citizens at the centre of Scotland’s economic policies

Next Post

BAE Systems building new shipbuilding academy at Clyde shipyard

Tanya Pia Starrett

Tanya Pia Starrett

Tanya Pia Starrett is a former Scottish solicitor living in Italy, born into a Glasgow Italian family. A graduate of both Glasgow and Edinburgh University, with a bachelor of law (LLB) and a masters of arts in archaeology and European medieval history. A teacher of English for more than ten years, she enjoys writing, campaigning and is an Italian national ambassador for Europe for Scotland. Interests are the arts, history and politics.

Related Posts

Families depicted
History

History on the edge – the Tinker experiment

byCharlie McCarthy
28 July 2023
Russia military and mercenaries conflict represented with a tank on a map
History

Nothing New Under the Sun: The Wars of the Three Kingdoms and the Wagner Uprising

byJoseph Cryan
29 June 2023
Oil in Scotland
History

Oil, Margaret Thatcher and Dinnae Mess Wi Us

byMartin Roche
14 May 2023
Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh
History

Scotland’s Road to Devolution

byMartin Roche
13 May 2023
Three women in medieval clothing looking at a ypung man in Viking dress with an axe and shield. A local man looks on from behind a tree.
Culture

St Brice’s Day Massacre

byAnna Schurer
16 February 2023
Next Post
Work being conducted underneath HMS Glasgow at BAE Systems' Govan shipyard. Photograph: ©John Linton 2022. All rights reserved. Courtesy of BAE Systems plc

BAE Systems building new shipbuilding academy at Clyde shipyard

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

Subscribe to our newsletters
CHOOSE YOUR NEWS
Follow us on social media
CHOOSE YOUR PLATFORMS
Download our app
ALL OF BYLINES IN ONE PLACE
Subscribe to our gazette
CONTRIBUTE TO OUR SUSTAINABILITY
Make a monthly or one-off donation
DONATE NOW
Help us with our hosting costs
SIGN UP TO SITEGROUND
We are always looking for citizen journalists
WRITE FOR US
Volunteer as an editor, in a technical role, or on social media
VOLUNTEER FOR US
Something else?
GET IN TOUCH
Previous slide
Next slide

LATEST

Scottish flag in Scottish sky

Brave are the hearts that beat …

23 September 2023
Hidden disabilities sunflower lanyard

Long Covid can be a hidden disability that we need to recognise

22 September 2023
Salmon in a fish farm without an eye

Worrying footage emerges from certified Scottish salmon farm

20 September 2023
edinburgh

Scotland’s capital is a hive of chip design and innovation

19 September 2023

MOST READ

No Content Available

BROWSE BY TAGS

Books Brexit Christmas ClimateChange Covid Covid19 Culture cycling Defence Democracy Devolution election ferry FishFarms Glasgow Halloween health History Holyrood independence IndyRef2 Journalism Labour LGBT+ Liz Truss Monarchy NATO NHS Nicola Sturgeon politics Poverty Russia Sars-CoV-2 Scotland Security and Defence shipbuilding SNP Sunak Tories Twitter UBI Ukraine UK Supreme Court vaccines War in Ukraine
Bylines Scotland

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Scotland and beyond.

Bylines Scotland is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a partner organisation to Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Privacy

© 2023 Bylines Scotland. Powerful Citizen Journalism

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Scotland
    • World
  • Politics
    • Council Areas
    • Europe
    • Holyrood
    • Rest of UK
    • Westminster
  • Business
    • Fishing
    • Trade
    • Transport
  • Health
  • Environment
    • Climate Change
  • Opinion
  • Donate
  • Newsletter sign up
CROWDFUNDER

© 2023 Bylines Scotland. Powerful Citizen Journalism

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In