• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Bylines Scotland
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Bylines Scotland Breaking News
    • Europe
    • King Charles III
    • Queen Elizabeth II
    • Scotland
    • War in Ukraine
    • World
    blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

    Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

    Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

    “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

    Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

    Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

    A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

    Saving Scotland’s tenements

    Ben Nevis. Forground has green shrubbery, then background a mountain with two tops. Blue sky with a few streaky clouds

    Exploring the Highest Mountain in the British Isles: A Guide to Ben Nevis

    Image via Steller Systems, a potential candidate.

    Cancelling future frigates could be final nail in the coffin for the UK

    A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

    Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

    A scene of people demonstrating, holding Scotland flags. One man wears a tartan cap and holds a blue flag with both the Scottish cross and the EU stars on it.

    Is Alister Jack sane?

    Cartoon by Stan

    Film reviews award season

    Trending Tags

    • Democracy
    • Devolution
    • Brexit
    • Ukraine
  • Politics
    • All
    • Council Areas
    • Europe
    • Holyrood
    • Liz Truss
    • Rest of UK
    • Tories
    • United Kingdom
    • Westminster
    • World
    blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

    Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

    A scene of people demonstrating, holding Scotland flags. One man wears a tartan cap and holds a blue flag with both the Scottish cross and the EU stars on it.

    Is Alister Jack sane?

    Image Malcom Laverty

    The Brown plan

    The climate change impacts of Russia’s war with Ukraine

    Britain wastes £1bn on drones to monitor English Channel

    The Autumn Statement – time to take a closer look

    Photo Mtaylor848, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

    Christmas cheer for Tesco if grim reading for the political classes

    Scottish independence isn’t going away

    Russia as a low-tech nation

    Trending Tags

    • Crime
    • Equality
    • Johnson
    • Scottish National Party
  • Business
    • All
    • Agriculture
    • Aviation
    • Corporations
    • Energy
    • Fishing
    • Natural Resources
    • Shipbuilding
    • Trade
    • Transport
    • Workers
    A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

    Saving Scotland’s tenements

    A large red researcgh vessel in the sea with ice sheets all around it on the water.

    Rosyth shipyard attracts UK Government contract to maintain fleet of scientific research vessels

    large posts saying 'Glasgow Airport Business Park' on the left and right of a road leading away from the main road in the front. . On that road leading away building with walls almost entirely existing of windows.

    Why doing business in Scotland may be better for your corporate wellbeing

    A mountain of spools forming a tree on the left, a sandy area to the right and a row of houses at the back. mountains in the distance on the right

    The Ullapool Giving Tree

    Electric off-roader heralds return of vehicle mass-production in Scotland after 40 years

    Photo Mtaylor848, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

    Christmas cheer for Tesco if grim reading for the political classes

    Ferguson Marine will weather the storm

    Order placed for remaining five Type 26 Frigates on the Clyde

    Police Scotland not investigating Scottish government over ferry contract criminality

    Trending Tags

    • Health
      • All
      • Assisted dying
      • Covid
      • Influenza
      • Polio virus
      • Respiratory
      • Scientific Research
      Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

      “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

      Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

      Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

      A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

      Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

      Two more unions reject Scottish Government NHS pay offer

      GMB union reject Scottish Government pay offer to NHS staff

      Lymphocites gathering

      How careful should we be when choosing a scientific term?

      Code Black – A mayday from the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital

      The challenges facing mental health care in Scotland

      Illustration by author

      What are the boundaries to push science to its safety limits for the benefit of discoveries?

      Trending Tags

      • Environment
        • All
        • Air Pollution
        • Biology
        • Climate Change
        • Wildfires
        Ardnish wildfire by Leslie Barrie, CC BY-SA 2.0 Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic — CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons'

        Fire threats in the Scottish countryside

        Wood stove at the foot of the bed in the Danish Blue room at Pig Hill Inn, Cold Spring, New York. Printed with permission and confirmed to be licensed under the terms of the cc-by-2.0.

        When smoke gets in your eyes

        Opening of the United Nations Climate Change Conference COP27 in Egypt. Photo courtesy of the UNFCCC

        COP27 and the inconvenient truth

        Viscum album in trees

        Night of the strangling figs: a biological horror story

        Out & about with Charlie Mac: Cycling to the heart of Scotland – the National Cycle Network 7

        Scotland's mountain footpaths

        How do we care for Scotland’s mountain footpath network?

        climate science

        PM to be chosen by people with little grasp of climate science

        Trending Tags

        • Opinion
        No Result
        View All Result
        • Home
        • News
          • All
          • Bylines Scotland Breaking News
          • Europe
          • King Charles III
          • Queen Elizabeth II
          • Scotland
          • War in Ukraine
          • World
          blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

          Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

          Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

          “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

          Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

          Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

          A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

          Saving Scotland’s tenements

          Ben Nevis. Forground has green shrubbery, then background a mountain with two tops. Blue sky with a few streaky clouds

          Exploring the Highest Mountain in the British Isles: A Guide to Ben Nevis

          Image via Steller Systems, a potential candidate.

          Cancelling future frigates could be final nail in the coffin for the UK

          A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

          Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

          A scene of people demonstrating, holding Scotland flags. One man wears a tartan cap and holds a blue flag with both the Scottish cross and the EU stars on it.

          Is Alister Jack sane?

          Cartoon by Stan

          Film reviews award season

          Trending Tags

          • Democracy
          • Devolution
          • Brexit
          • Ukraine
        • Politics
          • All
          • Council Areas
          • Europe
          • Holyrood
          • Liz Truss
          • Rest of UK
          • Tories
          • United Kingdom
          • Westminster
          • World
          blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

          Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

          A scene of people demonstrating, holding Scotland flags. One man wears a tartan cap and holds a blue flag with both the Scottish cross and the EU stars on it.

          Is Alister Jack sane?

          Image Malcom Laverty

          The Brown plan

          The climate change impacts of Russia’s war with Ukraine

          Britain wastes £1bn on drones to monitor English Channel

          The Autumn Statement – time to take a closer look

          Photo Mtaylor848, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

          Christmas cheer for Tesco if grim reading for the political classes

          Scottish independence isn’t going away

          Russia as a low-tech nation

          Trending Tags

          • Crime
          • Equality
          • Johnson
          • Scottish National Party
        • Business
          • All
          • Agriculture
          • Aviation
          • Corporations
          • Energy
          • Fishing
          • Natural Resources
          • Shipbuilding
          • Trade
          • Transport
          • Workers
          A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

          Saving Scotland’s tenements

          A large red researcgh vessel in the sea with ice sheets all around it on the water.

          Rosyth shipyard attracts UK Government contract to maintain fleet of scientific research vessels

          large posts saying 'Glasgow Airport Business Park' on the left and right of a road leading away from the main road in the front. . On that road leading away building with walls almost entirely existing of windows.

          Why doing business in Scotland may be better for your corporate wellbeing

          A mountain of spools forming a tree on the left, a sandy area to the right and a row of houses at the back. mountains in the distance on the right

          The Ullapool Giving Tree

          Electric off-roader heralds return of vehicle mass-production in Scotland after 40 years

          Photo Mtaylor848, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

          Christmas cheer for Tesco if grim reading for the political classes

          Ferguson Marine will weather the storm

          Order placed for remaining five Type 26 Frigates on the Clyde

          Police Scotland not investigating Scottish government over ferry contract criminality

          Trending Tags

          • Health
            • All
            • Assisted dying
            • Covid
            • Influenza
            • Polio virus
            • Respiratory
            • Scientific Research
            Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

            “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

            Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

            Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

            A hospital corridor with trolleys on the sides.

            Glasgow hospitals halt non-urgent operations due to pressure

            Two more unions reject Scottish Government NHS pay offer

            GMB union reject Scottish Government pay offer to NHS staff

            Lymphocites gathering

            How careful should we be when choosing a scientific term?

            Code Black – A mayday from the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital

            The challenges facing mental health care in Scotland

            Illustration by author

            What are the boundaries to push science to its safety limits for the benefit of discoveries?

            Trending Tags

            • Environment
              • All
              • Air Pollution
              • Biology
              • Climate Change
              • Wildfires
              Ardnish wildfire by Leslie Barrie, CC BY-SA 2.0 Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 Generic — CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons'

              Fire threats in the Scottish countryside

              Wood stove at the foot of the bed in the Danish Blue room at Pig Hill Inn, Cold Spring, New York. Printed with permission and confirmed to be licensed under the terms of the cc-by-2.0.

              When smoke gets in your eyes

              Opening of the United Nations Climate Change Conference COP27 in Egypt. Photo courtesy of the UNFCCC

              COP27 and the inconvenient truth

              Viscum album in trees

              Night of the strangling figs: a biological horror story

              Out & about with Charlie Mac: Cycling to the heart of Scotland – the National Cycle Network 7

              Scotland's mountain footpaths

              How do we care for Scotland’s mountain footpath network?

              climate science

              PM to be chosen by people with little grasp of climate science

              Trending Tags

              • Opinion
              No Result
              View All Result
              Bylines Scotland
              No Result
              View All Result
              Home News Scotland Independence

              Is the Union still a voluntary one?

              If the Union that currently exists between Scotland and the rest of the UK is no longer voluntary, what does this say about the state of our democracy?

              Richard HavilandbyRichard Haviland
              26-11-2022 07:00
              in Independence
              Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

              I don’t much enjoy writing or talking about independence. It goes against the grain for me. I’m forced to confront things I’d prefer to avoid. Challenges from friends or family can appear to carry a mildly accusatory tone, even if it’s only in my head.

              While I can furiously agree with my echo chamber (mostly Labour or Lib Dem voters) on the disaster of Brexit, or the horror show in Westminster, venture a pro-independence thought and there is an awkwardness, a new dividing line in a place where I never expected or wanted to have one. For everything I write or say, there’s a part of me that wants to unwrite or unsay it; to make it go away so that I can feel the same way that I used to about this United Kingdom.

              But I can’t stay silent and pretend I’m at ease when I’m not. Because there’s a problem, laid bare by this week’s entirely foreseeable but highly significant Supreme Court judgement. The UK I grew up believing in was, I thought, a voluntary union. One where we lectured, and still do lecture, other people about democracy and the right to self-determination.

              Yes, for most of my life, this may have felt largely theoretical because why would anyone, I would have reasoned to myself, want to leave?

              The Union I thought I believed in no longer exists

              But these days, when I hear some people insist that, while they personally oppose independence, the Union is a voluntary one, I wonder if they are being honest with themselves. Isn’t the truth that, for them, the question should always remain hypothetical? That when it risks becoming real, the best thing is to bide their time until that risk goes away, proclaiming without any obvious democratic or constitutional anchor that “now is not the time”, and insisting that, in the event this poll suggested that, or that election demonstrated this, there would of course be some sort of process but they just can’t say quite what it would be.

              That’s how it feels to me, anyway. And if I’m right, though it grieves me to say it, the Union I thought I believed in no longer exists.

              The Supreme Court judgement only reinforces this sense of disquiet. Not because it rules out a referendum at a time when I suspect many independence supporters – in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis – do not want one. Or even because referendums are the best way of resolving these things (I’m open-minded on that question). But because it makes clear that how and whether Scotland is ever to become independent will be entirely in the hands of Westminster.

              A voluntary union is dependent on the say-so of English MPs

              A series of questions flow from the Supreme Court decision. How can Scotland leave the UK if it wishes to? What process will there be for codifying this? How can it be right if Scotland’s ability to leave a nominally voluntary union is dependent on the say-so of English MPs? Why will Gordon Brown’s constitutional review not cover the possibility of independence for Scotland, even as the Labour-led Welsh government allows an Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales to imagine future independence for that country?

              In light of the Supreme Court judgement, these questions need to be put to Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat politicians, and their feet held to the fire. Because too often, I hear them talk about what they think the Scottish electorate ‘should’ have voted for rather than what it ‘did’ vote for, on multiple occasions. Too often they avoid the question of how Scots could hypothetically gain independence by telling us that Scots shouldn’t ‘want’ to.

              And then there are the slurs. In their world, there is no such thing as a legitimate complaint from an independence supporter – only a “contrived grievance”. There is no legitimate belief in self-government, only ugly anti-Englishness. There is no considered critique about the risks and challenges of independence (of which there are many) which won’t be tailed off with a pious lecture about the evils of nationalism.

              Image UK Government, OGL 3, via Wikimedia Commons.
              Politics

              Why do we need a Prime Minister?

              byIan Kinsey
              26 October 2022

              Scotland is divided into Yeses, Nos, Maybes, Don’t Knows and Deeply Conflicteds

              I’m sure these people are quite certain of the essential morality of their position. I don’t mean that nastily – in fact, in their strictures I can hear a fair bit of my former self, confident that proclaiming we’re “better together” is enough of an argument in its own right. But (and this goes for both sides) you need to be careful when you’re convinced of the morality of your position, as it can get in the way of your stated belief in democracy. Morality is about right and wrong. “Don’t kill”. “Treat refugees well”. These are moral positions. “Preserve the Union” isn’t a moral position, any more than is “gain independence”. These are matters of governance, or identity, or conviction. But not of morality.

              There’s a problem when politicians resort to this sort of language. It may fire up their base. But if the aim is to win converts, it achieves nothing. Scotland today isn’t divided into Yeses and Nos. It’s divided into Yeses and Nos and Maybes and Don’t Knows and Deeply Conflicteds, each with their own story to tell. Within my own circle of friends, I know a previously committed Unionist who would now vote Yes (“but would hate himself for it”), another who would vote No because of his fears about the economy (“but my heart would say Yes”), and another – her business destroyed by Brexit – genuinely torn between the absolute belief in the Britain she grew up believing in and the reality of the Britain that she sees today. How do lectures about the other side’s immorality help these people? Not one bit.

              Labour is not filling the gap on all key issues that’ll make a case for the union

              There is still a positive, progressive case to be made for the Union. It’s a tricky one, because it needs to be based on an acknowledgement that Brexit and all that has ensued from it is a disaster, and a resolution to overturn it and come through these disastrous years all the stronger. And it would need, of course, to be based on a reinforced sense that the Union really is voluntary, underpinned by a clearly set out route to independence in the event that Scots one day sought it.

              The problem is that Labour, the party you would expect to fill this gap, is not doing so. Where we would expect a Labour party to trumpet its internationalism, we hear its leader trying to outdo the Tories on immigration. Where we would expect a Labour party to condemn in the strongest terms the evils of the Tories’ Rwanda policy, we see a leadership which focuses instead on the impracticality, thus helping to normalise the evil and leaving room for Nicola Sturgeon to make the speech about refugees that you’d expect to hear from Labour.

              Where I would like a Labour party to tell me how my children can regain the freedom of movement that has been taken from them, I hear Labour not only telling me that they can’t but chiding me for wanting it. Where I see an electoral system desperately in need of reform so that we are never again held hostage by First Past the Post to socially conservative voters in a small group of English constituencies, I see a Labour party that shows no sign of wanting to reform that system. “We have to say these things”, they will tell you, “because the system forces us to”. Thus reinforcing the case for independence. And on it goes.

              Does the future of the Union depend on Labour?

              Maybe, despite my scepticism, Labour will once again flourish in Scotland, winning back seats from the SNP at the next general election.

              But what if it doesn’t? What then for the Union? What if the reality is one of an ever-growing assumption among younger Scots that independence is only a matter of time? Doesn’t that put a whole new challenge on saving the Union? Will harking back to the World Wars, the golden days of the BBC and the history of the labour movement, combined with lectures about the evils of nationalism, do the trick?

              Seen through that prism, doesn’t the future of the Union depend on Labour, in particular, being able to set out the kind of compelling, progressive vision for the future that for now it is singularly failing to do? On understanding that it needs to win people over to the Union with a positive vision that doesn’t insult their intelligence? On accepting that, if it wants to save the Union, it may need to be willing to take the risk of letting it go.


              We need your help! The press in our country is dominated by billionaire-owned media, many offshore and avoiding paying tax. We are a citizen journalism publication but still have significant costs. If you believe in what we do, please consider subscribing to the Bylines Gazette 🙏

              Tags: BrexitDemocracyDevolutionEnglish MPsScotlandScotland's right to determine its own futureSturgeonSunakToriesUK Supreme Court
              Previous Post

              Heartland FM wins Station of the Year at 2022 Community Radio Awards

              Next Post

              Scotland and economic life after independence

              Richard Haviland

              Richard Haviland

              Richard Haviland is a former civil servant with the Department for International Development, the Foreign and Commonwealth Office and GCHQ, and member of the European Movement in Scotland. He has written for the Times and Byline Times. He lives near Loch Ness.

              Related Posts

              A scene of people demonstrating, holding Scotland flags. One man wears a tartan cap and holds a blue flag with both the Scottish cross and the EU stars on it.
              Brexit

              Is Alister Jack sane?

              byMartin Roche
              15 January 2023
              John Swinney speaking at the SNP Conference, 15 December 2022
              Independence

              What will 2023 bring for the SNP?

              byCharlie McCarthy
              16 December 2022
              Supporters of Scottish independence in front of Holyrood, Edinburgh. Just one of the many rallies across Scotland following the UK Supreme Court decision rejecting Scotland's right to hold IndyRef2. Photograph by Paul Bassett
              Independence

              Independence campaigns on both sides will be different this time round

              byPaul Bassett
              30 November 2022
              Economy

              Scotland and economic life after independence

              byProfessor John R Bryson
              27 November 2022
              Yes rally Glasgow ahead of 2014 Independence Referendum.  Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic
              Independence

              The aftermath of the Supreme Court’s ruling on IndyRef2

              byCharlie McCarthy
              24 November 2022
              Next Post

              Scotland and economic life after independence

              Subscribe to our newsletters
              CHOOSE YOUR NEWS
              Follow us on social media
              CHOOSE YOUR PLATFORMS
              Download our app
              ALL OF BYLINES IN ONE PLACE
              Subscribe to our gazette
              CONTRIBUTE TO OUR SUSTAINABILITY
              Make a monthly or one-off donation
              DONATE NOW
              Help us with our hosting costs
              SIGN UP TO SITEGROUND
              We are always looking for citizen journalists
              WRITE FOR US
              Volunteer as an editor, in a technical role, or on social media
              VOLUNTEER FOR US
              Something else?
              GET IN TOUCH
              Previous
              Next

              LATEST

              blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

              Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

              31 January 2023
              Healthcare word seen in a scrabble

              “Leave no one behind” – the Health Foundation’s report into health inequalities in Scotland 2023.

              30 January 2023
              Sign saying NHS Greater Galsgow & Clyde in front of a hospital building

              Concern over patients waiting in corridors for free beds at Glasgow Superhospital

              27 January 2023
              A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

              Saving Scotland’s tenements

              27 January 2023

              MOST READ

              blue background, A younf woman holding a large black sign that says VOTE ! in white letters

              Scottish elections: young people more likely to vote if they started at 16 – new study

              31 January 2023
              close up picture of part of a violin

              Amateur orchestra delivers rousing performance in first post-lockdown concert

              26 January 2023
              A row of tall houses on the left, with parked cars in front on the side of the street

              Saving Scotland’s tenements

              27 January 2023
              Image via author, printed with permission.

              Glasgow’s ‘Ambition’ for Ukrainian Refugees – A look at the ship facilities

              23 September 2022

              BROWSE BY TAGS

              Alister Jack Brexit Christmas Climate change cost of living crisis Covid Culture Defence Democracy Devolution Gender Recognition Reform Glasgow Halloween health History Holyrood independence IndyRef2 Johnson Journalism Liz Truss Long Covid Monarchy nationalism NATO NHS Nicola Sturgeon politics Poverty Putin Russia Sars-CoV-2 Scotland Security Security and Defence shipbuilding SNP Sunak Supreme Court Tories Tourism Twitter Ukraine UK Supreme Court War in Ukraine
              Bylines Scotland

              We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Scotland and beyond.

              Bylines Scotland is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times.

              Learn more about us

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Bylines network
              • About
              • Authors
              • Contact
              • Donate
              • Privacy

              © 2022 Bylines Scotland. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              No Result
              View All Result
              • Home
              • News
                • Scotland
                • World
              • Politics
                • Council Areas
                • Europe
                • Holyrood
                • Rest of UK
                • Westminster
              • Business
                • Fishing
                • Trade
                • Transport
              • Health
              • Environment
                • Climate Change
              • Opinion
              • Donate

              © 2022 Bylines Scotland. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

              Welcome Back!

              Login to your account below

              Forgotten Password?

              Retrieve your password

              Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

              Log In