Scotland is often said to have a much more robust left-wing tradition. Yet Neil Mackay feels that, even here, progressive perspectives do not get the hearings they should. In fact, both Mackay and Rhiannon Davies challenge the idea that Scotland can simply assume it is insulated from the political developments affecting England, Europe and the United States. Mackay warns of the danger of complacency in assuming that Scotland’s stronger progressive and left-wing history will make it immune to polarisation or far-right politics.
He points to an important difference in Scotland and Northern Ireland: the media landscape has historically developed differently from that of London. Much of the Scottish and Northern Irish newspaper tradition grew out of local newspapers rather than being created entirely by national billionaire-owned organisations. But that distinction is increasingly threatened by the decline of local journalism.
For Mackay, the disappearance of local newspapers is one of the great underreported crises in British democracy. Local papers once provided the basic infrastructure of civic life. They reported local councils, courts, schools, disputes, celebrations and community events. They provided a shared source of information for people who might disagree politically but lived in the same place. Their decline has created a vacuum that has allowed the far right to flourish.
Davies makes a similar case for independent local journalism. A community publication can provide voices that are frequently absent from national coverage and can tell stories without relying solely on the news values of large commercial organisations. Citizen journalism can also broaden the range of people who are able to participate in public debate.
While Mackay cautions against assuming that everything produced outside mainstream journalism is automatically good journalism, he also believes citizen journalism can be a powerful medium of communication when appropriately used. For him, journalists, whether trained or citizen, require particular skills: curiosity, research, an understanding of law and politics, the ability to assess evidence and, crucially, the ability to explain complicated subjects accurately to people with very different levels of education.
What happened to complexity?
Both Mackay and Davies return repeatedly to the disappearance of complexity from public debate. Mackay remembers a time when newspapers, radio and television regularly carried lengthy discussions of politics, history, culture and science. People might have disagreed with the conclusions, he says, but there was a shared expectation that complicated questions could be discussed in complicated ways.
Today, political communication increasingly happens through short posts, videos, headlines and fragments. The incentives are different. The story that says workers are striking for better pay is less immediately dramatic than the story saying commuters have been disrupted. The story about structural poverty is harder to package than the story about an individual incident. The story about a complex immigration system is less emotionally immediate than a story built around a confrontation.
That does not necessarily mean journalists deliberately distort reality. It means the structure of the modern news environment can favour particular kinds of stories.
Davies argues that constructive journalism offers one possible alternative. It does not mean positive journalism or avoiding bad news. It means reporting problems while also examining their causes, possible responses and the people working to address them. That approach can help challenge the negativity bias of news without becoming propaganda. Instead of simply asking what went wrong, journalists can also ask why it happened and what could change.
Social media and the loss of trust
For Neil Mackay, the arrival of social media has intensified almost every existing problem. He compares it to a knife: something that can be used constructively but can also cause enormous harm. He argues that while mainstream journalists face legal and professional consequences when they make serious false allegations, social media users can make similarly damaging claims with few immediate consequences.
That imbalance has created a fragmented information environment in which professional journalism competes against millions of individual accounts. Regulation, he argues, has to address this issue without destroying the legitimate freedoms social media has created.
The difficulty is that social media has become deeply embedded in everyday life. Mackay describes watching younger generations grow up in an environment of constant scrolling, where information, entertainment, advertising and political messaging are mixed together. The danger, he believes, is not simply that people encounter extremist ideas. It is that they lose the ability to distinguish between reliable information, propaganda, advertising, opinion and entertainment.
Davies believes journalism must respond by rebuilding trust rather than simply complaining about social media. That means transparency, accountability, community engagement and a commitment to accuracy.
Rebuilding local journalism
For both interviewees, one answer lies in rebuilding journalism closer to the communities it serves. Neil Mackay remembers local newspapers as imperfect but important institutions. They were not necessarily ideological. Their purpose was to record what was happening in a particular community. That created a shared civic space.
Their economic model, however, was vulnerable. Local newspapers depended heavily on advertising, and the internet destroyed much of that revenue. As advertising moved online, local news organisations lost the financial base that had sustained them. The consequences went far beyond the disappearance of familiar newspapers. When fewer journalists attend council meetings, fewer people scrutinise local government. When fewer journalists attend local courts, fewer cases are reported. When fewer reporters know the people and institutions of a particular area, communities can become invisible until something dramatic happens.
That matters to the far-right debate because communities that feel ignored can become fertile territory for political narratives built around resentment. A healthy local press can provide another narrative: one rooted in the actual experiences of people living in a place.
Davies’ work at Greater Govanhill represents one version of that model. It is journalism that begins with the community rather than simply arriving to extract a story.
What can ordinary people do?
Neither interviewee suggests there is a simple technological or political solution. Mackay is sceptical about the possibility of simply reversing the changes brought by social media. His hope lies partly in the possibility that audiences may eventually become more selective about what they consume. In a world flooded with algorithmically generated content and increasingly sophisticated artificial intelligence, he believes human-made journalism may eventually become more valuable precisely because audiences know where it came from.
That could create a premium for trustworthy brands and journalists. But it will not happen automatically. People also have a role. That can mean supporting local newspapers and independent publications, checking sources before sharing stories, challenging sensational claims, reading beyond headlines and resisting the temptation to reward outrage with attention.
It can mean asking why a story is being framed in a particular way.
It can mean distinguishing between legitimate disagreement and deliberate dehumanisation.
And it can mean becoming involved in local civic life rather than assuming politics happens only in Westminster, Holyrood or online.
Davies’ own approach is rooted in community. She believes journalism can bring people together rather than simply reflecting existing divisions. That might mean public meetings, local reporting, citizen journalism, conversations across political differences or simply creating spaces where people who feel isolated discover that others share their concerns.
Mackay confirms this analysis. He believes political and economic reform is ultimately necessary, particularly around the influence of money in politics and the regulation of social media. But he also believes people need to reclaim the idea that democracy belongs to them.
The media we choose
There is a tension at the heart of the argument. The public often complains about sensationalist journalism while continuing to consume it. Mackay is blunt about this. The media is, in part, a reflection of what audiences reward. If outrage generates clicks, publishers have an incentive to produce outrage. If sensational headlines sell newspapers, newspapers will continue using them. If social media users share inflammatory material millions of times, algorithms will continue to identify that material as valuable. Changing journalism therefore requires changing the relationship between audiences and the media.
It also requires journalism to take responsibility for the power it has.
The press cannot simply say that it is reporting what people want to hear.
It helps shape what people believe is important.
It decides which voices are heard and which are ignored.
It chooses whether migrants appear primarily as statistics, threats, victims, workers, neighbours or individuals with complicated lives.
It decides whether a far-right gathering is described simply as a protest, or whether the ideology, organisation and objectives behind it are properly investigated.
It decides whether poverty is presented as an individual failure or examined through the economic and political structures that produce it.
These choices matter.
Beyond the boiling frog
The conversation returns to an image of a frog slowly being boiled in water: a metaphor for societies becoming accustomed to changes that would once have seemed unacceptable. Mackay worries that Britain is living through such a moment. He sees the normalisation of extremist language, the weakening of institutions, economic inequality, the decline of trust and the fragmentation of the media as interconnected developments.
Yet neither he nor Davies argues that the outcome is inevitable. There are still journalists investigating powerful organisations. There are independent publications building communities. There are citizens organising locally. There are young people creating new forms of solidarity. There are movements using social media to challenge injustice as well as movements using it to spread hatred.
The question is which of these forces society chooses to strengthen.
For Mackay, journalism remains part of the answer precisely because it remains one of democracy’s essential institutions. For Davies, journalism has an obligation not merely to describe communities but to consider what its descriptions do to them.
The press can feed fear or challenge it.
It can make minorities into targets or allow them to speak for themselves. It can reduce political disagreement to outrage or explain why people disagree. It can chase the next click or investigate the problem beneath the headline. And it can either accept the disappearance of local journalism as inevitable or help rebuild the civic spaces that once allowed communities to understand themselves.
The far right does not operate in a vacuum. It grows within particular economic, political and cultural conditions, and it is able to exploit the weaknesses of existing institutions.
That does not make journalism responsible for the rise of the far right.
But it does mean journalism has choices. Perhaps the most important is whether to treat audiences as consumers of outrage or citizens capable of understanding complexity. In an age when anyone can publish instantly, the distinction between journalism and content has never been more important.
The task is not to silence difficult conversations about immigration, inequality, public services or social change. It is to have those conversations without allowing extremists to define the terms. It is to investigate grievances without turning minorities into scapegoats. It is to report extremism without normalising it. And it is to remember that democracy requires more than people having the freedom to speak. It requires citizens having access to reliable information with which to decide what to believe, who to trust and what kind of society they want to build.
That may be the most important role the press still has.








