Through the ages, stories have explored what it means to be a part of a community; modernity seems to lazily grasp the literal, foregoing the invitation to dig deeper.
In the fairy tales of old, gold and vast treasure were never merely material. They stood as potent metaphors for wisdom – the hard-won understanding that sustains societies, fosters truth, and equips generations to live well. Saint George slaying the dragon to claim its guarded hoard, or Jack climbing the beanstalk to seize the golden goose that promised abundance: these stories encoded a deeper truth.
Real wealth flows from insight into human life, nature, and the structures that allow flourishing. The dragon represents chaos or entrenched power to be confronted with courage; the golden eggs symbolise generative wisdom, not hoarded riches that multiply without effort or ethics.
Today, that integrative wisdom appears in desperately short supply in Scottish political discourse. Dominated by figures like Malcolm Offord, John Swinney, and Ross Greer, debate reveals a fragmented, reductive approach to systemic problems. As Iain McGilchrist might describe it in his book The Matter With Things, we fixate on isolated parts – targets, taxes, investments – while missing the living whole. Policies chase symptoms or ideological priors rather than cultivating the generative understanding needed for a sovereign, prosperous Scotland.
Political point-scoring dominates debate while an ever more stretched electorate require strategies that promise a secure future and a solid foundation to build on. The current discussion appears infantile and reminiscent of the fairytales of old. The reductive nature of proposals for serious contemporary problems results in scapegoats and sticking plaster fixes. Our politicians must widen their perspective and act like responsible leaders rather than automatons.
Green Greer and the dragon’s hoard
Once upon a time in beautiful Scotland, a cry went up: “Help us! There is a dragon hoarding all the housing!” Green MSP Ross Greer and campaign groups like Living Rent point to holiday lets and owners of multiple properties as the cause of scarcity, strained services, and lost communities. They propose new taxes – an “Offord tax” – to slay this beast and redistribute the hoard.
Look closer, as any wise storyteller would. Owners of second homes and holiday accommodation are often absent for much of the year. They register for doctors, vote, and pay taxes elsewhere. They do not crowd out permanent residents from local schools or surgeries. Far from draining resources, these properties bring visitors who sustain pubs, shops, restaurants, ferries, and tradespeople. They inject money into fragile rural economies without demanding constant public services.
The real giant at the top of the beanstalk is not the second-home owner, but chronic failure to build enough new homes. Decades of under-investment in public housebuilding have left supply lagging demand. The private sector cannot build where procuring materials costs more than the market price for a home. Planning rules, regulatory thickets, and reluctance to treat housing as a foundational national priority have compounded the problem.
Blaming existing property owners distracts from the generative solution: abundant new supply, particularly from local government. This could be underway if vast public sector pension funds were directed toward local procurement. Unlocking these funds would allow Scots to invest in themselves even under current UK constraints.
A wider perspective recognises that meaningful public investment on the required scale is unlikely under present constitutional arrangements. Only with independence can Scotland guarantee sovereign control of resources to treat housing as the crucial human need it is – directing capital, land, and policy toward building homes in volume at rents ordinary families can afford.
The Green Party, to which Greer belongs, already stands for independence and wellbeing. Aligning fully with that logic would mean prioritising public housebuilding as the heart of the independence case, rather than fixating on redistributing existing stock. Holiday homes are not the villain; insufficient public provision and investment are. Our pursuit of the golden eggs of wisdom and understanding will reveal themselves more readily if everyone is guaranteed basic necessities from their local government – including beautiful, comfortable, healthy housing – for ongoing abundance.
The tale of the foreign monarch’s coin
In another corner of the Kingdom, First Minister John Swinney conjures visions of independence through foreign direct investment (FDI), swiftly re-establishing European Union membership, and continued use of sterling. This, he suggests, will bring prosperity and status.
Ancient stories warn that blind acceptance of foreign largesse leaves people vulnerable to Trojan horses. Relying on the currency of the UK hands monetary policy to the Bank of England, whose decisions reflect the larger neighbour’s cycles and priorities. EU alignment brings regulatory and fiscal oversight limiting independent decision-making. Joining the Eurozone combines both. FDI can deliver jobs and capital, yet often comes with strings: profits flowing outward, policy influence, and dependence.
True sovereignty requires control of currency, borders, and resource distribution. An independent Scotland should focus on domestic capital formation, skills, innovation, and institutions tailored to strengths in energy, food, tourism, and advanced manufacturing. The goal is meeting domestic living standards desires today, to build foundations for better standards tomorrow. Sovereignty does not require a parochial outlook, but forms the basis for international brotherhood on equal terms with our neighbours in the UK, Europe and the wider world, outside of exclusive clubs,
Celebrating FDI headlines while planning to use another nation’s (UK) money and join another union (EU) risks an independent Scotland emerging weaker and more constrained – still paying tribute, still lacking the full toolkit of self-determination. Sovereignty cannot be gifted or borrowed. It must be earned through asserting the electorate’s will and courageous institution-building at home. Infiltration and corruption through economic and political Trojan horses become obvious to a vigilant populace and will be rejected.
The tale of the boastful merchant
Not long ago, Reform UK’s Scottish leader Malcolm Offord attended a debate, proudly declaring his six houses, five cars, and six boats. He presented himself as the model Scotland needs more of – a successful businessman who employs people and pays taxes.
In old stories, a lord crowing over overflowing coffers signalled pathological inequality, where wealth concentrates because the soil no longer yields for the common folk. Offord’s unflinching focus on material gains is indicative of a society that has lost an understanding of true value.
Success in a healthy nation should be a measurement of contribution to broad improvement – being part of a tide lifting all boats. A tide, that should be gratefully recognised, that has built over centuries of such advancement. Critics on the left call for heavier taxation to balance the accounting. A wiser approach examines why the economic soil feels barren for so many: monopolisation of essentials, pension tax exemptions, foreign aid black holes, and policy choices that fail to compound generational progress.
Tax wealth heavily to reduce the influence that largesse has on democracy. Tax is not necessary to do what is required for the population as a whole. In fiat economies like the UK, the government can spend to put to work unemployed resources in the nation for the public good.
Lord Offord is right that entrepreneurship and wealth creation matter. But a healthy system celebrates not how many yachts one man owns, but how many families can securely own modest homes, raise children without dread, and see living standards rise steadily. Celebrating isolated success without reforming conditions for widespread opportunity misses the tale’s moral. All of the children of the next generation are the wealth creators of the future.
Reclaiming the treasure
Scotland’s current system suffers from a shortage of integrative wisdom. It fragments problems into ideological slogans – tax second homeowners, attract foreign capital on foreign terms, envy or celebrate the multimillionaire – rather than seeking the living whole. It lacks courage to confront root issues: constitutional limits on public investment, regulatory barriers to building and enterprise, and reluctance to prioritise long-term human flourishing.
Scotland possesses real strengths – natural resources, educated people, distinct identity. Independence offers the possibility of directing resources toward genuine public goods like abundant housing, while building sovereign institutions suited to Scotland’s needs. That path requires clear-eyed prioritisation of supply over redistribution, domestic strength over external dependence, and broad prosperity over spectacle.
The nuggets of golden understanding in tales of the past were never effortless. They required confronting chaos, diligent stewardship, and insight into what truly generates abundance. Without such wisdom, no tax, investment announcement, or boast will unlock the hoarded treasure.
Friends of Bylines Network
There has never been a greater need for grassroots journalism that investigates the stories that really matter, holds power to account and champions the voices of everyday citizens. We are proudly powered by volunteers but what we do isn’t free.
STAND WITH US for independent, citizen-led journalism that makes democracy stronger, and you will even get some exclusive benefits.
